
Injuries and mortality among the conscientious objectors was
higher than in the general military that they refused to participate in.
re-instated and a citizen told to report for conscription, there may be
only a week or two available to apply for Conscientious Objector
status, and the resolution of the case often depends on being able to
document that the beliefs of the draftee have been long-standing.
During the American Civil War a young member of Ohio Yearly Meeting
found himself on the wrong side of the dominant culture when it came to
taking up arms against his fellow man. Nathan Blackburn
was a Pennsylvania reisident who was drafted in 1863.
Conscientious objectors were treated severely at that time.
Nathan was shipped off with the troops. After cooperating in
initial drill training, he decided that to continue was inconsistent
with his beliefs. Nathan writes of a typical week, "I again attempted to regain my
position by refusing to take my part in the performance and one day
they had me bucked and gagged (as they call it) most of the day.
The next day I was jerked around, knocked down, beat over the head,
kicked several times and tied up by the thumbs for a while, then put on
the ground on my back with a bayonet through my mouth with the ends
tied to two sticks, and my hands tied and then left to lay in the sun
for some time, then tied up by the thumbs, so changed back and forth
two or three times..."
Today Ed Kirk
is a recorded minister of Stillwater Monthly Meeting, but as a young
man in 1944 he was of one of the first smokejumpers in the United
States. At that time various Quaker, Mennonite, and Brethren
conscientious objectors were assigned the high-risk job of parachuting
into northern forests using the primitive equipment of the time to
fight forest fires on the ground. The work was very
dangerous--note the neck armor and the helmet with the steel mesh
faceshield to protect the firefighter as he dropped into the
treetops. Ed broke his back in his last jump and volunteered to
finish the rest of his assignment doing clerical work in the camp
office.
During
training, he explained to his commanding officer that his beliefs did
not permit him to carry a gun, but that he would do whatever else he
could to serve faithfully. His options at that time were
immediate discharge, gravedigger, or medic. Myron was reassigned
as a medic, and returned home to Ohio after the war. He is the
soldier second from the left.
Bob believes that it isn't enough to just oppose war, or the
preparation for it. He states, "CO's have an obligation to
participate in some kind of work which will reduce human suffering,
promote understanding between different peoples and nations, or in some
other way reduce the tensions and other causes of war. I think
that only when we as CO's can offer and participate in constructive
alternatives to military service can we make positive steps towards the
elimination of military service."
Lewis Stratton,
of Short Creek Meeting, believed that it was important to serve his
country in some manner that would be beneficial. As a Friend, he
cooperated with his draft board and opted for one of the formal
Alternative Service work plans. In 1957, Lewis and his wife Wanda
were sent to Madhya Pradesh in central India. As an Ohio farmer,
Lewis became the "Agriculturalist" and Wanda worked as a nurse.
The project was administered by the American Friends Service
Committee. Lewis taught modern irrigation techniques (not always
successfully), and helped dig modern wells for both irrigation and
household water.
In 1942, the 20-year-old Ray Stanley
was classified 1-A by his draft board, and discussed the matter at
length with them in the subsequent hearing. Ray agreed to take on
non-combatant service and was sent to Maryland to clear trees from the
Pocono swamp. Soon afterwards, Ray volunteered to serve in the
American Friends Service Committee's medical unit as a human guinea
pig. Ray's assignement was to undergo dehydration study, which
involved no and low-protein diets for a year while various foods were
tested, including gum arabic, soybeans, and various amino acids.
The studies were not benign. One volunteer died, one was
discharged on mental grounds, and Ray was hospitalized twice.![]() Photo by Wesley Schultz Desmond Doss |